The 2025 NFL Draft has concluded its first round, bringing a wealth of fresh talent into the league. From dynamic quarterbacks to two-way stars and elite defensive playmakers, teams across the NFL made critical decisions that will shape their futures for years to come. This comprehensive analysis breaks down all 32 first-round selections, examining team needs, prospect profiles, and the potential impact of each pick.
Table of Contents
- Introduction: The 2025 Draft Landscape
- Top 5 Picks Analysis
- Quarterback Selections and Team Fits
- Picks 6-10: Rising Stars and Immediate Contributors
- Picks 11-20: Mid-Round Value and Team Strategies
- Picks 21-32: Late First Round Steals
- Draft Winners and Losers
- Future Impact: How the 2025 Class Shapes the NFL
- Conclusion
Introduction: The 2025 Draft Landscape
The 2025 NFL Draft arrived with massive expectations, featuring one of the most talented quarterback classes in recent memory alongside elite defensive talent and versatile playmakers. Taking place in Green Bay, Wisconsin from April 24-26, the draft launched an unexpected series of trades and surprising selections that challenged conventional wisdom about prospect values.
With significant trades reshaping the draft order, including the Jaguars' bold move to acquire the second overall pick, and several surprise selections, the first round delivered on excitement. While offensive linemen dominated with eight total selections, the headlining stories focused on unique talents like dual-position star Travis Hunter and Miami quarterback Cam Ward. Let's dive into the complete breakdown of each selection and what it means for both the players and their new teams.
Top 5 Picks Analysis
Cam Ward, QB, Miami
The Titans selected Miami quarterback Cam Ward with the first overall pick, addressing their long-standing need for a franchise signal-caller. Ward combines exceptional arm talent with impressive mobility and playmaking skills, offering Tennessee the potential for an immediate offensive upgrade.
Travis Hunter, WR/CB, Colorado
In the draft's first major surprise, Jacksonville made a blockbuster trade with Cleveland to select Hunter, the rare two-way star who excelled at both wide receiver and cornerback at Colorado. The Jaguars gave up significant draft capital, including a 2026 first-round pick, for the unique talent that new GM James Gladstone called "the crown jewel of the draft."
Abdul Carter, EDGE, Penn State
The Giants selected the explosive pass rusher from Penn State, bolstering a defense that tied for eighth in the NFL with 45 sacks last season. Carter's exceptional first step and refined technique made him the consensus top edge defender in the draft, with analysts giving this selection an "Elite" grade.
Will Campbell, OT, LSU
The Patriots prioritized protecting second-year quarterback Drake Maye by selecting Campbell, LSU's standout left tackle. New England's offensive line was a clear weakness in 2024, and Campbell's exceptional footwork and strength make him a day one starter expected to anchor the line for years to come.
Mason Graham, DT, Michigan
After trading down from the second pick and acquiring significant draft capital, the Browns selected Michigan defensive tackle Mason Graham. His combination of power and technical refinement makes him an elite interior defensive lineman who can collapse pockets and stuff the run, providing immediate impact to Cleveland's defense.
Quarterback Selections and Team Fits
The 2025 draft class featured only two quarterbacks selected in the first round, far fewer than many analysts projected entering draft night. While Miami's Cam Ward went first overall to the Titans, Colorado's Shedeur Sanders—widely projected as a top-10 pick—surprisingly fell out of the first round entirely.
The New York Giants made an aggressive move to get back into the first round, trading with Houston to select Ole Miss quarterback Jaxson Dart at #25 overall. This became an even bigger story when they passed on Sanders, who had been linked to several quarterback-needy teams throughout the pre-draft process.
Jaxson Dart completed his senior season at Ole Miss with impressive performances that caught scouts' attention. His strong arm and mobility made him a riser late in the draft process, though some analysts questioned whether the Giants gave up too much to select him, with PFF grading the pick as "Below Average."
As for other notable quarterback prospects, both Alabama's Jalen Milroe and Louisville's Tyler Shough remain available heading into day two. Their fall, along with Sanders', sets up an intriguing second round with several teams still in need of quarterback help.
Picks 6-10: Rising Stars and Immediate Contributors
Ashton Jeanty, RB, Boise State
The Raiders surprised many by selecting Jeanty with the sixth overall pick, making him the first running back off the board. His exceptional 2024 season (2,601 rushing yards, just 28 shy of Barry Sanders' NCAA record) and unique blend of power, speed and agility made him an analytics favorite with a Next Gen Stats prospect score of 95 - the highest among all 2025 prospects.
Armand Membou, OT, Missouri
The Jets continued to build protection around Aaron Rodgers by selecting Membou, a powerful tackle who earned second-team All-SEC honors in 2024. A relative newcomer to football who didn't play until eighth grade, Membou's rapid development and athletic upside made him an appealing option for a Jets team looking to maximize its short window with Rodgers.
Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona
Carolina added a much-needed weapon for quarterback Bryce Young by selecting McMillan, considered by many to be the top wide receiver in this class. At 6'5", the Arizona standout brings exceptional size, catch radius, and production, having finished his collegiate career with 3,423 receiving yards (an Arizona program record) and 26 touchdowns.
Kelvin Banks Jr., OT, Texas
The Saints surprised many by passing on quarterbacks like Shedeur Sanders to select Banks, a three-year starter at Texas with exceptional technique and athleticism. This selection signals New Orleans' commitment to quarterback Derek Carr for the immediate future while solidifying an offensive line that struggled with consistency in 2024.
Colston Loveland, TE, Michigan
Chicago continues building around rookie quarterback Caleb Williams by adding Loveland, the draft's top tight end prospect. The Michigan standout brings exceptional receiving skills and improving blocking ability, giving Williams another reliable target alongside DJ Moore and Rome Odunze in what's becoming one of the league's most promising young offenses.
Picks 11-20: Mid-Round Value and Team Strategies
The middle portion of the first round featured several teams addressing critical needs, particularly on the defensive side of the ball. The San Francisco 49ers selected Georgia defensive end Mykel Williams at #11, adding another elite talent to their already formidable defensive front.
Dallas continued its investment in the offensive line, selecting Alabama guard Tyler Booker at #12, though some analysts considered this a reach with Booker ranked 48th on PFF's big board. The Miami Dolphins strengthened their defensive interior by selecting Michigan defensive tackle Kenneth Grant at #13.
The Indianapolis Colts added another pass-catching weapon by selecting Penn State tight end Tyler Warren with the 14th pick, while the Atlanta Falcons addressed their linebacker corps with Georgia's Jalon Walker at #15. Arizona found exceptional value with Mississippi defensive tackle Walter Nolen at #16, receiving one of the draft's highest grades for this selection.
Cincinnati bolstered their defensive front with Texas A&M's Shemar Stewart at #17, while Seattle surprised many by selecting North Dakota State offensive lineman Grey Zabel at #18. Tampa Bay added another weapon to an already loaded receiving corps by selecting Ohio State's Emeka Egbuka at #19, and Denver addressed their secondary with Texas defensive back Jahdae Barron at #20.
Picks 21-32: Late First Round Steals
The final third of the first round featured several playoff teams adding complementary pieces to already talented rosters, along with a few teams trading back into the round to target specific players.
The Pittsburgh Steelers opted for Oregon defensive lineman Derrick Harmon at #21, passing on quarterback Shedeur Sanders in a move that suggests their commitment to Aaron Rodgers for the immediate future. The Los Angeles Chargers selected North Carolina running back Omarion Hampton at #22, giving new coach Jim Harbaugh the powerful runner his offense requires.
Host city Green Bay selected Texas wide receiver Matthew Golden with the 23rd pick, their first first-round receiver selection in 23 years, while Minnesota bolstered its offensive line with Ohio State guard Donovan Jackson at #24.
Two of the most notable moves came late in the round. First, the New York Giants traded back into the first round to select Ole Miss quarterback Jaxson Dart at #25, giving them a potential quarterback of the future. Then Atlanta made what many considered the draft's most questionable move, trading a 2026 first-round pick to select Tennessee edge rusher James Pearce Jr. at #26 after already addressing the same position earlier in the round.
Baltimore may have found one of the draft's biggest steals when Georgia safety Malaki Starks fell to them at #27, while Detroit continued building its defensive line with Ohio State's Tyleik Williams at #28. Washington added offensive line help with Oregon tackle Josh Conerly Jr. at #29, and Buffalo strengthened its secondary with Kentucky cornerback Maxwell Hairston at #30.
Philadelphia traded up one spot to #31 to select Alabama linebacker Jihaad Campbell, considered the top inside linebacker in the draft. Finally, defending Super Bowl champion Kansas City closed out the round by selecting Ohio State tackle Josh Simmons at #32, ensuring quarterback Patrick Mahomes remains well-protected.
Draft Winners and Losers
Winners
The Jacksonville Jaguars emerge as clear winners after making the bold move to trade up for Travis Hunter, a unique two-way talent who could revolutionize how NFL teams think about position versatility. Their new general manager James Gladstone made an immediate statement with this aggressive move.
The New York Giants also had a strong first round, landing elite pass rusher Abdul Carter at #3 overall and then trading back into the first round to select quarterback Jaxson Dart. This balanced approach addresses both immediate needs and future planning.
Titans fans should be excited about Cam Ward, a dynamic quarterback who brings both experience and playmaking ability to a franchise that's waited patiently for a true franchise signal-caller. His confident personality and impressive production at Miami make him an ideal fit for Tennessee's rebuild.
The Philadelphia Eagles and GM Howie Roseman continued their draft excellence, waiting until the end of the first round to add Alabama linebacker Jihaad Campbell, filling a critical need without overpaying.
Losers
Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders suffered the draft's most surprising fall. Despite being projected as a top-10 pick just weeks ago, Sanders wasn't selected in the first round, raising serious questions about his evaluation by NFL teams.
The Atlanta Falcons' front office made the night's most questionable decision, trading a 2026 first-round pick to move back into the first round for Tennessee edge rusher James Pearce Jr. after already selecting Georgia linebacker Jalon Walker earlier. This aggressive move for a player many considered a second-round talent could haunt them next year.
The New Orleans Saints passed on the opportunity to select a quarterback at #9 overall, instead taking Texas offensive tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. While Banks is a quality prospect, this decision suggests the Saints are committed to Derek Carr despite mixed results in 2024.
Browns fans experienced a rollercoaster evening when the team traded away the second overall pick—and a chance at Travis Hunter—for additional draft capital. While they received significant compensation and still landed Michigan defensive tackle Mason Graham at #5, many fans had spent months dreaming of Hunter's potential impact on both sides of the ball.
Future Impact: How the 2025 Class Shapes the NFL
This draft class features several potential franchise-altering talents, none more intriguing than Travis Hunter. The Colorado two-way star's selection by Jacksonville marks a potential shift in positional specialization, as the Jaguars have indicated plans to utilize him on both offense and defense—something not seen in the modern NFL era.
The quarterback selections proved less impactful than expected, with only Cam Ward and Jaxson Dart going in the first round. Shedeur Sanders' fall could dramatically shift team strategies heading into day two, with several quarterback-needy teams now having a chance at a prospect many considered worthy of a top-10 selection.
The heavy emphasis on offensive line selections (eight total in the first round) reflects an increased league-wide focus on protection and run-blocking following several seasons of defensive dominance. Teams clearly prioritized keeping their quarterbacks upright and establishing physical rushing attacks.
Defensively, this class featured exceptional talent across all three levels, with edge rushers, interior defenders, linebackers, and defensive backs well-represented. Abdul Carter to the Giants and Mason Graham to the Browns could immediately upgrade their respective defensive units.
Conclusion
The 2025 NFL Draft's first round delivered excitement, surprise selections, and potentially franchise-altering decisions for several teams. The Jaguars' bold trade for Travis Hunter could reshape positional versatility standards, while Cam Ward gives the Titans their long-awaited franchise quarterback.
The fall of Shedeur Sanders provides one of the draft's biggest storylines heading into day two, while the heavy investment in offensive line talent reflects the league's cyclical nature as teams adjust to years of defensive innovation.
From Travis Hunter's two-way potential to Ashton Jeanty's record-setting production, this draft class brings exceptional talent to the NFL. The true impact of these selections won't be known for several years, but the immediate reactions suggest a draft class rich in both high-end talent and depth across premium positions.
As rookie minicamps begin and these players integrate into their new teams, fans across the NFL landscape have legitimate reasons for optimism about what these first-round selections will bring to their franchises.
